In the cake vs. pie face-off, PIE took the cake. 😉
The competition, which took place on Jezebel.com, ended when cheesecake beat red velvet cake by receiving 59% of the votes. (Apparently cheesecake is a pie because of its crust.)
I finished third in my work bracket standings. I had ice cream cake going all the way, but sadly it lost to red velvet in the quarter-finals.
So, do you agree? Would you pick cheesecake over red velvet cake?
Ummm, no, I wouldn’t. Red velvet cake ALL THE WAYYYY!
Kelly says
Mmmm absolutely! Love cheesecake, especially with fresh strawberrys!
janetha says
i am all about red velvet. but i do love cheesecake. OH. you know what would be absolutely fabulous? graham cracker crust.. layer of cheesecake.. layer of red velvet cake.. cream cheese frosting. yum.
peanutbutterfingers says
the cheesecake factory actually makes a red velvet cheesecake! ryan & i ordered it on our anniversary. it’s delicious!! http://peanutbutterfingers.wordpress.com/2010/02/01/anniversary-dinner/
coffeeismycarrot says
Cheesecake all the way! The real New York kind, though
Tina says
In the words of Joey from Friends….put those hands together baby! 😉 Just like you did when you went to the CCF.
lisaou11 says
haha!
midgetkeeper says
Red velvet for me. Love cake.
Gabriela @ Une Vie Saine says
I’d absolutely pick red velvet over cheesecake. Cheesecake is a cake in my book, so the two shouldn’t even be competing!!
Genie says
How ’bout a red velvet cheesecake?! Mmmmm!
*Andrea* says
i would totally pick cheesecake 🙂 i loveeee the chocolate chip peanutbutter cookie dough cheesecake from cheesecake factory. so decadent and delicious!!
Kelly says
ICK! I hate cheesecake! Red Velvet would have been my pick hands down!
Alison says
I have never really been a fan of cheesecake…it is way too rich for me! Cake is definitely MUCH better! Especially ice cream cake! 😉
Candice says
I’m usually a pie person over cake, but not if cheesecake is considered a pie. Too rich for me. I’d have picked Red Velvet cake. Or, like you, I’d go for the ice cream cake!
kaitm says
I would totally pick red velvet before cheesecake…it kinda has the best of both worlds with the cream cheese frosting on top!
homecookedem says
I’m not a cheesecake fan, so DEFINITELY would pick red velvet!! 🙂 I love the cream cheese frosting!!
Megan (from Happily Healthy) says
I would definetely have Philadelphia cheesecake (made by my mom) topped with cherries over red velvet cake anyday! But black forest takes the cake over any dessert in my eyes!
MelissaNibbles says
As I commented on Jezebel, I consider this a win for Team Cake because both are cakes.
I had red velvet going all the way though…so yay me for almost winning!
Mellissa says
This was too funny, I can’t eat either because of the cream cheese so I would have picked German Chocolate
Molly says
OH I LOVE CHEESECAKE i just wish it was better for you :o) It is so creamy and rich yum