Peanut Butter Fingers

Living a Life Fueled by Healthy Food and Fitness

Navigation

Shopping Secondhand: How To Find Items You’ll Love (+ $250 Giveaway!)

by 435 Comments

When it comes to shopping secondhand, you can find some amazing deals and trendy items if you know how to shop! thredUP is my go-to resource for online consignment shopping and today’s post breaks down exactly how I find items I absolutely love. Be sure to check out the discount code and awesome giveaway at the bottom of this post for your chance to go on a $250 thredUP shopping spree! Thank you to thredUP for sponsoring this post!

How to Shop Secondhand with thredUP

If you’ve been reading this blog for longer than a hot second, you’ve likely picked up on the fact that I do a lot of my personal shopping and shopping for Chase on thredUP. I discovered the site back in 2014 and it has been a go-to resource for high-quality secondhand clothing for me ever since!

thredUP is the largest online store that buys and sells like-new secondhand clothing and accessories for women and kids. (You can find top name brand and designer clothing for up to 90% off retail!) I have purchased everything from workout apparel to designer bags to new-with-tags baby and toddler clothing from the site.

thredUP Box

Everything arrives at your doorstep wrapped in beautiful striped tissue paper and I’ve never once had an issue with the quality of an item I’ve ordered. And if sizing or fit is a concern, returns are a breeze and free (if you opt for store credit which I always do) or you simply pay the price of return shipping if you prefer a refund.

In today’s post, I wanted to break down some of my favorite secondhand shopping tips for you guys so you can hopefully find some awesome and affordable clothing and accessories on thredUP as well! Let’s get to it!!

How to Find Items You Will Love on thredUP

  • Get Specific

This is probably my number one piece of advice I have for finding something you will love on thredUP! I am all about searching for specific brands but I’ve stumbled upon some new-to-me brands I ended up loving on thredUP by searching for specific items. This is especially handy when I want to try out a new trend but I’m not looking to spend a ton of money on certain items.

By searching for specific items like a denim vest, black and white romper, pink crop top or floppy hat, I can find specific items I’m interested in purchasing without limiting myself to the brands or stores I frequent in my day-to-day life.

Example:

thredUP Romper LOFT

Last summer I fell in love with rompers and the minute the weather began warming up in Charlotte this spring, I searched for rompers on thredUP. I found this romper from Ann Taylor LOFT for only $20 by searching for wrap-style rompers (retail value: $70)!

  • Search For Your Favorite Brands

When it comes to shopping for clothes, most of us have brands we know and love. There are a handful of brands I shop for over and over again because I know I can usually find something that will both flatter my body type and match my personal style. I will often search thredUP specifically for these brands and since I am very familiar with my size in clothing from my favorite brands, it helps me find items that are often a hit! For example, I love the brand Yumi Kim and know the dresses from this brand are typically feminine and flattering to my body type.

Example:

yumi kim thredup dress

After searching for Yumi Kim dresses, I found this beautiful pink and navy dress last summer on the site for only $30 (retail value: $143). Chase’s outfit is also a thredUP find! (Carters Polo + Carters Pants for $5 + $7!)

  • Search By Style/Fit

Most of us know what fits flatter our body type, so searching thredUP for certain items by specific style is very helpful! I know fit and flare is a style that generally works well on my body type since I have wider hips and a booty but am a little slimmer through the waist, so I search for this fit when I look for dresses. When it comes to items like jeans or shorts, searching by style (skinny, high-waisted, cropped, etc.) can be very helpful and narrow your search to a more manageable amount of items to browse.

Example:

thredUPtshirt dress

I was in the market for a super-casual dress I could wear with my Converse sneakers and searched for a t-shirt dress with a fit-and-flare style on thredUP. I stumbled upon this Uniqlo dress with a cinched waist for $14.99 (retail value: $48) and it totally fit the bill!

  • Search for Old Favorites

Have you guys ever fallen in love with a certain brand’s jeans or a pair of sneakers only to find them discontinued or the style dramatically changed? thredUP has helped me locate past favorites and discontinued items more than a few times! I actually just found the mint green Baby GAP polo Chase wore on his first birthday in his current size on thredUP last month and ordered it immediately because I loved the way the shirt looked on him so much!

Jump Rope Workout

Example:

I’ve had great luck finding lululemon activewear that I swear is almost brand new (or actually brand new with tags!) on the site by searching for my sizes in this brand regularly. The above top is one of my favorite racerback style tanks that I’m fairly certain the brand discontinued because I haven’t been able to find it in store or online in months. I bought it on thredUP for $30 (retail value: $58)!

  • Check Back Often

When I was searching for a black backpack, I checked thredUP quite often since I figured a black backpack is an item that’s not too obscure and would likely pop up on the site semi-frequently. thredUP is updated ALL THE TIME (they add thousands of items per hour) so new items constantly appear on the site. When I have something specific in mind that I know is a relatively popular item, I peek around the site and search for a specific item and more often than not, I’ll luck out and something will appear within a couple of weeks.

Example:

Small Black Faux Leather Backpack

I searched thredUP for about a week for a small black backpack earlier this month and quickly snatched up this like-new one from Forever 21 for $17.99 (retail value: $35) the minute I saw it pop up on the site!

thredUP Giveaway + Discount Code 

And now I have some good news for you! thredUP is offering the first 100 people an additional 40% off their first order with the code JULIE40. (Discount code applies to new US customers only. Discount up to $50.)

If you’re looking to do some serious shopping on thredUP, I also have the chance for one reader to win a $250 shopping spree on the site! To enter the giveaway, simply browse thredUP and comment back here with a link to one item that stuck out at you. I will randomly select a winner next Friday.

Good luck!!

Be sure to follow PBFingers on Instagram and Facebook!

I'd love to connect with you! I am always so grateful when you let me know you tried one of my recipes or workouts and tag me in your photos or updates. Thank you so much!!!

About Julie

My name is Julie and I am a full-time blogger, new mama, fitness enthusiast (certified personal trainer and group exercise instructor) and food fanatic (mostly healthy... but also not-so-healthy) living in North Carolina with my husband, dog and baby boy. Thank you for visiting Peanut Butter Fingers! I hope you enjoy little glimpses into my life and have fun trying the sweaty workouts I frequently share and making some of my favorite recipes along the way!

Comments

  4. Juliette says

    I love ThredUp! I’ve mostly sent my old favorites there but haven’t made use of really searching online for new items. I love the backpack, I didn’t realize they had more than just clothing!

    Reply

    • Julie says

      I do it ALL the time for Chase, too!! So great! Especially since most kids wear clothes for 2.5 seconds before it’s on to the next size!

      Reply

  9. Caylin says

    Amazing giveaway!
    I actually just sent in a bag for resale. I am needing to purchase a toddler snow suit for next winter and have my eyeeye on an L.L.l Bean purple bib. I have the app and wasn’t able toddler post a link.

    Happy shopping everyone!

    Reply

  30. Laura Gallegly says

    ThredUp is so great! I spotted some cute New Balance shoes I would definitely buy for my toddler if I won the giveaway! Plus some spring clothes for myself. : )

    Reply

  41. Wren says

    I have always worn and loved jeans by American Eagle, but they recently changed the fit and material of their jeans so they no longer flatter me. This site looks perfect for finding some pairs of the older styles I loved but need to replace!

    Reply

  45. Amber says

    I’ve always looked at the site for cute stuff, but never pulled the trigger and purchased anything. I have always been concerned about fit and quality with online places. I have found that it is hit or miss with most places.

    I love long cardigans like this one:
    https://www.thredup.com/product/women-soft-surroundings-cardigan/24073129?sizing_id=579%2C832%2C576%2C829%2C822%2C812

    or cute skirts like this one:
    https://www.thredup.com/product/x-eileen-fisher-casual-skirt/24097672?sizing_id=579%2C832%2C576%2C829%2C822%2C812

    now with a 4month old I LOVE shorts like this (so cute):
    https://www.thredup.com/product/boys-gymboree-shorts/17863123?shortcut=3541&sizing_id=579%2C832%2C576%2C829%2C822%2C812%2C80%2C84

    I can’t even deal with the cuteness of these board shorts:
    https://www.thredup.com/product/boys-carters-board-shorts/18688343?sizing_id=579%2C832%2C576%2C829%2C822%2C812%2C80%2C84

    Reply

    • Taylor says

      I placed this dress in my cart and went to look at a few other things and when I clicked my cart it was empty and I can’t find the dress again. I’m assuming that until you checkout then someone else can buy it even though it’s in your cart?

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

Disclaimer

I am not a registered dietitian. My blog is simply a documentation of my life. The views I express are mine alone, based on my own experiences, and should not be taken as medical advice. I DO NOT post everything I eat. Though I am a certified personal trainer, the workouts I post may not be right for you. Please speak with a medical professional before making any changes to your current routine.

Affiliates

Please note that affiliate links may pop up on PBF from time to time. I greatly appreciate your support!
Privacy Policy